This recipe calls for pickled red onions. Like all Mr. Keller's recipes. There's always something in the ingredients that has to made a day before. I made the pickled red onions a few hours before... and they still tasted great. Next, I decided to boil the lobsters. All other times I've made lobster, I've just steamed them. But after this, I might change the way I make lobsters all the time. In ad hoc, Mr. Keller has you make a broth bath full. I also noticed that most of the recipes on the internet don't include this step. Not sure why, I think it made the lobster meat taste extra juicy.
So in the broth I chopped up leeks, fennel, onions, celery, thyme, tarragon, water and salt... I got the water warm, but not boiling. I added the lobsters head first and then said good bye and shut the lid. I'm always sad when I have to kill living animals... at least this time they didn't fight back. I brought the brine up to a boil. Then removed the pot from heat and let the lobsters sit in the bath for about 15 minutes. then when I opened the top - voila! cooked lobsters. Mr.keller has some directions on how to extract the meat. He even had a helpful tip on how to get the meat out of the little legs. By the time I was done picking these bad boys meat out, my hands felt raw and soggy. Soooo over picking lobster meat.
The rest of the recipe was easy. I chopped up all the ingredients and then mixed it with some olive oil mayo from the store. For the buns I followed the directions by spreading butter on the buns and pan frying them. That made the buns almost crispy and strong enough to hold the lobster fixings.
I also added some cherry tomatoes to the recipe. (Only because I like tomatoes in sandwiches). Then while eating the sandwich I realized that the pickled red onions really went well with the lobster.... so then I added a ton more to my sandwich.
Will I ever make this again? Probably not. Even thought I scored lobsters for $5.99, I spent even more buying all the ingredients to just make the broth to cook them in... I think each sandwich came out to $10-14 each. dang, imagine if you bought it at a restaurant?? yikes!
Here is the recipe from ad hoc (that I copied from the internet.... because i'm too lazy to copy from the book)
Lobster Rolls
Ingredients:
- 1 1/2 lbs (about 4 cups) cooked lobster
- 3 to 4 tbs mayonnaise
- 2 tbs minced red onion
- 2 tbs finely chopped peeled celery
- 2 teas finely chopped tarragon
- 2 teas finely chopped flat-leaf parsley
- 2 teas finely chipped chives
- Kosher salt and freshly ground black pepper
- 1/2 lime
- 6 New England-style (top-split) hot dog buns or other hot dog buns
- 4 tbs unsalted butter, melted
- 1 celery stalk
- 1 head butter lettuce, leaves separated, rinsed, drained, and torn into pieces
- Pickled red onions
Preparation:
Put the lobster meat in a large bowl, add the mayonnaise, and stir
gently to coat. Add the onion, celery, tarragon, parsley, chives, and
salt and pepper to taste and stir gently to mix. Squeeze the lime over
the salad and fold in the juice. Cover and refrigerate.
If using top-slit buns, brush butter on both outer sides of each bun.
If using unsliced buns, slit them open from the top, then trim each
long side to create a flat surface and brush with melted butter. If
using regular hot dog buns, open the buns and brush with butter. Heat a
frying pan over medium-high heat. Just before serving, put the rolls in
the pan and brown the buttered sides.
To serve, peel the strings from the celery with a vegetable peeler.
Using a Japanese mandolin or other vegetable slicer, or a sharp knife,
slice the celery lengthwise into thin ribbons. Line each bun with a
couple of small pieces of lettuce. Mound the lobster salad in the buns
and garnish with the celery and picked red onions.